I have had many therapists on my mental health journey. Some have taught me what doesn't work in therapy, while others have inspired me to live a safer and happier life. By therapist, I should clarify I don't necessarily mean someone with letters after their name. I count as a therapist anyone I reached out to with whom I had a rapport and who, in turn, provided support. This includes a friend, a sibling, a family doctor and professional therapists. I have had therapists for one conversation and others for weeks, months and years. What is most important to me is that they listened without judgment. I rarely reach out for help, and when I do, I hope they accept me with compassion and trust.
My mental health is not something anyone else can remedy. It has to come from within. A good therapist will not try to solve my mental challenges, but they will listen and, through their patience, help me find my way. A therapist should help me foster self-compassion (see Chapter on Self-compassion) and encourage me to take the time to step back and recognize my distorted thinking to realize the way forward or at least the next step.
The first official therapist (with credentials and everything) I ever had was in University, right after I was hospitalized for my second attempt. I resented having to go. They told me that if I didn't, they would kick me out of residence. I didn't take kindly to the threat and was prepared to get my apartment when I finally acquiesced.
She was a middle-aged woman. Very relaxed. We started by first sorting out my family dynamic. She brought out chess pieces and asked me to identify every family member with a playing piece. I then had to explain my choices. I selected my dad as king. He was the head of the family. Dinner was served when he got home. He was a family doctor. I love my dad. He was always generous with his time. We played lots of games together. We had pentathlon tournaments where we played five events: ping pong, billiards, cribbage, Pente and chess. My father was my role model. Despite my mental challenges, I have always given my best to my two children.
I identified my mother as the queen because she was the most powerful member of the household. She knew everything that was going on and when it was to happen. The house ran like clockwork. Her agenda on the counter was a blueprint for the week. Every meal was accounted for. Every appointment was recorded. I was the youngest in my family by four years, so "my mother" was different from my siblings'. From about age 14 and forward, I was virtually an only child. While my siblings were off at college or University, my mother and I had extended one-on-one contact. If my dad was not home for dinner, the two of us would go out to a restaurant. At night, we used to watch TV together. Remington Steele was a favourite. We had a very close relationship.
My mother was proud of me when I was young. I always did well in school. It was a running joke between us that she always left the same comment on my report card. "We are very pleased with John's report." In elementary school and high school, my academic trajectory seemed infinite. I had plans to become a Latin Professor (see Chapter on Latin), which my mother highly encouraged. She had a friend who was a university professor, and his life was a success. But that didn't quite turn out for me. Unfortunately, in post-grad school, she was no longer pleased with "my report." She never said anything openly about it until much later when, under the shadow of Alzheimer's, she told me none of her children amounted to anything.
When I was younger, in elementary school, My mother had a mental breakdown. She went to the hospital for a few days. I remember buying her a special edition of Life magazine dedicated to Queen Elizabeth. My mother was a royalist. I gave it to her just as she was leaving for the hospital. I don't know any of the details of her condition or if she even had a diagnosis. Like most families, we didn't talk about mental health. All I remember is that she seemed happier after the stay.
My one sister also lives with mental health challenges, which have been quite severe over the years. I remember visiting her at the hospital once when she was in isolation. It was meant to keep her physically safe but did nothing for her mental health. The room was dark, hospital green. There were no drapes or fixtures. The only furniture was a bed devoid of bedding with wrist and ankle restraints. There was a large window on one side where a nurse kept us under constant observation, again to keep my sister from harming herself. During my visit, I shared some pictures on my iPod, and we laughed a little. Without furnishings, our voices echoed in the hollow space. It was such a dismal room. Luckily, I have never been put into solitary confinement. (see Chapter on Hospitals)
I identify this sister with the knight chess piece. She always liked horses. She even took riding lessons when she was younger. The therapist thought my reasoning was humorous. Being closest to me in age, I played with my knight sister the most. I remember how we would "act out the music" from the Beatles album Help! We would jump and dance and roll around in the basement. We also used to play down in the valley by the creek. We made bowls out of the raw clay we found. Once, we even wandered inside a huge culvert left open during construction. It was scary and thrilling at the same time. The further we went in, the darker it got. I had a very happy childhood. Lots of adventures.
My other older sister I identified as a rook. My reasoning was that she was very organized and methodical. She babysat me the most when I was a kid. We were not playmates, but we did have a close relationship. She looked out for me, and I trusted her judgment. She comforted me when I had my first mental breakdown (see Chapter on Music). When I threatened another suicide attempt at University, they asked who I could talk to to calm me down, and I identified her.
Similarly, thirty years later, she was the only one I talked to over the phone. I love my father, but he prefers to solve problems rather than listen. In crisis, you don't want to be healed, just heard. My mother, at that time, had advanced dementia, though I probably would have never called her. She often talked about my knight sister being overly dramatic with her mental health. I doubt I would have said anything. I wouldn't want to disappoint her. Her's was the British way - keep a stiff upper lip and carry on. My Rook sister would listen as I cried. She was my first therapist back when I stopped my piano lessons. (see Chapter on Music).
I assigned the Bishop to my brother, who was eight years older than me. He stood up for me many times in my life. I remember at summer camp where he was a counsellor, and I was a camper. Other campers didn't realize we were related, and one in particular addressed me, "Hey you!" My brother immediately stepped in and said, "He has a name." I don't know why that stands out. I guess I never had someone stand up for me like that. My brother also never played by the rules. On the rare occasions when he babysat me, everything was different. I remember we mixed a huge pitcher of chocolate milk. Normally, we did it one glass at a time. Also, we played a game when it was time to go to bed. He held our globe and spun it. If it stopped on North America, I had to turn out the lights and go to sleep. Anywhere else, I could stay up. It seemed like the perfect game. I had Europe, Asia and the Pacific and Atlantic oceans. I couldn't lose. And indeed, for a time, I didn't lose. Of course, eventually, America won, and I went to bed. Only later in life did I realize my brother was manipulating the results. He knew when I would lose by how much pressure he put on the spinning globe. Nonetheless, he still made it a game, letting me stay up at least ten minutes beyond bedtime. I remember when he woke me up in the middle of the night and told me to get into his brown Camaro (It was the 70s. He was cool!) while I was still in my PJs. We drove north until we had left all the street lights behind. He then pulled over to the side of the road by a cornfield. He told me to look up, and there they were - the Northern Lights - dancing behind their gossamer curtain. Beautiful!
My brother did have a bit of temper, and I remember him and my dad arguing over dinner. At the time, I had no idea why they were shouting. The loud noise scared me and shut me down. I vowed never to fight like that with anyone, to always follow the rules, and to always keep others happy. I put school first and internalized conflict. Only later did I find out my brother was more interested in rugby than academics at high school and that most of the arguing was over homework.
I saw myself as a pawn. I was the youngest and not very important. Everyone else watched out for me. I was hospitalized twice as a young child with asthma. One Halloween, when I was at home ill, all my siblings took out an extra bag to collect candy for their sick brother. I had the most treats ever that year. Another time, they built a massive snow dinosaur to cheer me up. It was truly impressive.
I have always been an introvert. As a child, I was timid and often played alone after school. Not because I didn't have any friends but because I preferred my own company. When I was in kindergarten, I used to ask my mother for a carrot to feed the rabbit. She would give me one that was washed and peeled. I then sat on the grass alone in the backyard for an hour or so, patiently waiting for a rabbit to approach me. When I finally gave up, I ate the carrot myself and lied that the rabbit had come to visit.
Once I had sorted my family by chess piece, we examined the interpersonal dynamics. Other than my brother's occasional outbursts, there was not much to tell. There was no drama. My parents didn't fight, at least not in front of me. Occasionally, the rook sister and bishop brother would argue over borrowing the car. That was never an issue by the time I could drive. I could have the vehicle virtually anytime I wanted. I have lived a charmed life. That is why I consider my illness as more nature than nurture. I was born with depression, just like my mother and sister.
Talking to a therapist was a new experience for me. I had never had someone show so much interest in what I thought. And she didn't care whether I spoke on one topic or many simultaneously. She encouraged me to say whatever came to mind. In our first session, I related how annoyed I was that I was being forced to see her. She listened, and by the end of the session, I agreed to come back the following week.
I rarely looked into her eyes. I was ashamed. I cried so much. I was amazed at how cathartic it was. I had always tried to follow my mother's expectation to have a stiff upper lip and carry on without complaint, but to release it all was such a relief. I don't even remember why I was crying, and it didn't really matter in the moment.
Crying was therapeutic but not enough. I began cutting myself for an even deeper release (see Chapter on Latin). My therapist was very concerned but didn't tell me to stop. She knew that if she scolded me or demanded me to cease, I would not be as open with her, and I would guard what I said in the future. Instead, with her eyes full of tears, she told me that I was important to her and that we needed to explore why I needed to cut myself. Because she didn't panic, I trusted her. And after a few weeks, the injuries no longer provided relief. I remember how she smiled the first time I came to therapy without a fresh injury.
I didn't see another therapist until I contacted my family doctor some thirty years later. I'm not sure why I chose her. I had become her patient only one year before when I needed a doctor to sign off that I was physically able to do an EA (Educational Assistant) job. I barely knew her, but for some reason, I opened up to her before anyone else in my life. She was very kind and listened as I rambled and cried. She was very generous with her time. At one point, I was going in twice or three times a week; She recognized my distress and how dangerous it was. Her primary goal was to keep me safe. She was not entirely comfortable with mental health. She tried desperately to find me a therapist or pdoc, only to learn there were waiting lists that lasted months if not years.
It finally came to a head when I revealed I had attempted the night before. Not a very serious one, but it showed her I needed much more help than she could give. She "formed" me, took away my freedom and sent me to the psychiatric ward at the local hospital (see Chapter on Hospital). At the time, I was terrified, but in hindsight, it was the best option.
When you're in the hospital, the psychiatric nurses check in with you one or two times a shift. Some are excellent listeners, others not so much. I remember asking a male nurse if what I said about my depression made sense. I considered suicide as an accomplishment, as an expression of free will. Without even hesitating, he said, "No." I didn't talk to him after that. He missed out on a chance to help. It would have been much more productive if he said, "Tell me more." or asked questions to elicit further details. When someone has built up enough courage to say something, don't dismiss their words. It leaves them gutted and much more cautious in the future. Just by listening, you help validate their pain. You want to get them out of their heads and their dark thoughts and draw them away from suicide ideation.
One of the most helpful "therapists" was my best friend. We would meet about once a month at a Swiss Chalet or Denny's. He would travel by train and I by car, and we would meet halfway. I don't like talking on the telephone, so this was the best way to meet up. Besides, it's always fun to eat out for lunch. I would tell him what was on my mind and tear up as I spoke. Most of the time, I just looked at the cutlery on the table. He didn't mind and listened without judgment. He helped me so much just by being there. His embrace when it was time to go told me how deeply he cared.
When you are released from the hospital, it is challenging to find an accredited therapist. If you don't have enough money to hire one directly, your options are community counselling services, urgent care at a hospital, a mood disorder clinic, and Employee Assistance Programs (EAP). For some of these, such as community counselling and EAP, you contact yourself, while hospital urgent care and mood disorder clinics require a referral from your family doctor. Be advised that there can be lengthy waiting lists, as with all mental health services. From my experience, EAP provided the fastest access to a professional therapist.
She was one of the best therapists I have ever had. With my permission, she kept my family doctor in the loop. It didn't feel like I was starting over but instead enhancing my care. Together, they provided the intense support I needed at that time. I was in a very dark place. I remember her asking me at the end of a session whether she would ever see me again, and I said I didn't know.
She was the first to identify the Critic (see Chapter on Critic). We even had him "sit" in an empty chair so we could talk to him, and on occasions, I would sit there and say precisely what the Critic thought. It helped to draw a distinction between my depression and myself.
Unfortunately, the EAP had an expiry date. She managed to fudge the system a couple of times, so I got 12 weeks instead of 6, but like all therapy, it eventually ended.
This is a problem with all free or subsidized therapy. They all have a set number of sessions available, usually somewhere between 6 and 10 weeks and nothing more. The demand for services is too high.
All therapists keep a close eye on the clock. Sessions never run longer than the set time, regardless of what sort of breakthrough or crisis might happen. One therapist scolded me for not taking my anti-anxiety medication before visiting with her. She told me it would have saved a lot of time in session. I understand that they are very busy and need to keep on schedule. It is just that some therapists are better at managing session times than others. I'm not trying to scare anyone away from therapists. All of them were trying their best. I'm just explaining why some were not a good fit for me.
I had one therapist tell me, in no uncertain terms, that we would not "crack me open." She was only interested in discussing my immediate concerns. Since we only had five more sessions, we could not "waste" any time. She insisted on eye contact and good posture, both of which made me anxious during the session. If I slouched, she would stop our conversation and tell me to sit up straight. If my eyes wandered or looked down in shame, she would call my name so I would refocus. If my foot started to quiver, she would tell me to put my heel down flat on the floor. My mind was constantly told to focus on my physical state instead of my mental health. I have always had a bad posture. My head is a heavy weight on my neck. It droops forward in front of my body, and when I walk, my eyes tend to focus on the ground directly in front of me. It is a way of hiding in open space. As I left a session, she even advised me to "pinch my buttocks together" to straighten my back and roll my shoulders down. I didn't find this helpful.
When our session was over, I left exhausted. I had no reference point for therapy at that time, so I figured I just had to endure and hope for the best. Then suddenly, in one of our sessions (I can't even remember what I was saying) exasperated, she stopped me mid-sentence to ask if I even wanted to get better. I was stunned by her outburst. I had thought I was making progress that day. She wrote something down in her notes and then informed me we only had one session left. I shut down after that. I didn't return for the last session. What was the point?
Another therapist's introduction was so rehearsed right down to the hand movements and head nods that he seemed robotic. He had clearly seen many patients over his career. An incandescent lamp provided subtle lighting. It was meant to be cozy. It felt New Age to me. I wouldn't have been surprised if there was a special crystal somewhere or a little water feature. I sat in a chair right by the door. He sat in front of his desk, relaxed and reassuring. I think he wore a brown sweater. He was much younger than me: full head of hair and not a hint of grey.
After his initial spiel, he mentioned he was a Star Trek fan. I don't know if that was part of his rehearsed introduction or if he assumed from my square glasses that I was interested in Sci-fi. I replied that I liked Doctor Who. He responded that he would not hold it against me. I knew he was joking, but it took me back.
He next started his sales pitch, declaring that his approach was scientifically proven to be effective. At the time, he was the first, but I quickly learned that when therapists start talking about "scientific proof," they are about to mention Cognitive Behavioural Therapy. (see Chapter on CBT). Don't get me wrong. I have found CBT to be very effective, but only in group therapy. With individual therapists, it was a matter of filling out worksheets over six weeks without any insight or success. It was a structured way to waste time.
These were early days, and I didn't yet have a successful medication strategy. My emotions were all over the place (see Chapter on Medication). As I began introducing myself, I suddenly broke down and started crying uncontrollably. He sat back and watched until I regained my composure. He then ate a banana as he contemplated my situation. I was confused. I think it was supposed to be soothing. Of all the fruits, it is the gentlest. It's skin is easy to peel. The fruit is soft but not messy. The flavour is mild and agreeable. And it is the fastest-selling fruit at the grocery store. At the time, it seemed very random.
He then stood up, and we went to see his affiliated pdoc. (see Chapter on Pdocs). Her office was quite large with lots of papers strew around. My therapist introduced me to the pdoc, and we exchanged pleasantries. She then asked me a few questions. As I related my thoughts, I broke down again. The therapist immediately jumped in and said, "See, this happened before, lasts a few minutes and then it stops."
They then proceeded to have a conversation about my symptoms in front of me. The few minutes he referred to was the time it took me to recompose myself. The pdoc then wrote out a prescription, and I was sent on my way. (See Chapter on Pdocs)
That was the first and last time I saw that therapist. I decided to go with the EAP from my wife's employee health plan. I did contact him again when I had used up all my EAP sessions. I wanted to see how soon I could see him. At that time, I was just desperate to find another therapist. He informed me that I had been removed from his waiting list and that it would be another three months if I wanted to see him again. I didn't even bother to add my name.
I then went to subsidized therapy. A community wellness program ran it. I paid $50 a session. The first therapist I saw was an older woman with a thick Russian accent. I told her my challenges, complete with my uncontrollable tears. She paused for a bit, then quoted Freud. I didn't recognize the quote or remember it, but she made sure that I knew that she knew Freud. She then pronounced that I needed six sessions to be set right. Her confidence stole mine.
I decided she wasn't for me. So, I asked if there was someone else I could work with. I was glad I spoke up. The next therapist turned out to be helpful. She asked to see my writing. I brought a leather-bound notebook that included prose and poems throughout my life. I have a number of these notebooks now. It's so much nicer to write in than a Staples notebook. I did not record my thoughts chronologically. I wanted to make it clear that they have always been there in some form or another. I did, however, date each entry. I also included some of my naive drawings. She flipped through it and was taken aback by how pervasive and persistent my thoughts were. She gave it back and thanked me for sharing. I liked her because she tried to get to know me beyond my depression. The problem again was our time was limited by the subsidy. And after six sessions, I was sent on my way.
Another type of therapist is the crisis centre call line. This is part of my safety plan. If I'm suicidal and feel imminent, I'm supposed to call the crisis hotline immediately. I must admit I didn't initially like the idea of calling for help or using the telephone. I had images of the Ghostbusters hitting a panic button and sending the police with sirens blaring and a social worker in tow. (see Chapter on Hospitals) After all, they warn of that option on their website (minus the Ghostbusters). I didn't want to be taken into custody. I already knew what that felt like.
Nevertheless, one night, I felt imminent and made that first call. As soon as the crisis centre answered, they asked me where I lived and then promptly told me I had the wrong number. They offered no further assistance other than supplying me with a new number for my region. I guess it had to do with municipal funding. Whatever the case, it seemed to be a flaw in the system, after all, I was suicidal at the time. It was lucky I had enough resolve to call a second number.
When I finally got hold of someone in my jurisdiction, she proved to be very helpful and, to my relief, didn't hit any panic buttons. She remained calm and understanding for the entire call. She listened to me talk and then offered advice on settling my thoughts. We practiced mindfulness techniques together (see Chapter on Strategies), and by the time I was off the phone, my crisis had passed.
While a crisis line therapist does not replace full therapy, they are a handy resource in the moment. Make sure you get the correct phone number and write it down on paper. I keep mine in my wallet.
I now have a steady therapist. I knew that whatever disease I had it was not something that six sessions could cure. After using all the free or subsidized therapy available, I had to decide what to do moving forward. I knew I needed someone to talk to regularly and not on the phone. I finally decided that my mental health was important and that I had to find the money to invest in myself. I hired a therapist directly. We meet biweekly at $150 per one-hour session. The benefit of a long-term relationship is a deep understanding. Our sessions are more like conversations between friends than therapy. I have gained a new perspective on many issues. I was fortunate enough to find someone who was a good fit.
Am I cured? No. I still struggle with my mental health and suicide ideation, but at least now I have someone I can talk to every other week who can monitor my level of distress and the danger I am to myself. It helps to get me out of my darkest thoughts and put aside my suicidal intentions, even if it is just for an hour. All I really want is to write and hold hope for the future. Therapy gives me that chance.